Switching group retirement providers

What happens when you switch providers?

Plan new payroll contributions and existing savings separately. Agree on the work, the people responsible and the dates before announcing a move.

Meet with RiskX

One move. Two separate tracks.

New payroll contributions

  1. Set up accounts and payroll
  2. Send the first contributions
  3. Check amounts credited

Existing employee savings

  1. Confirm instructions and authorizations
  2. Arrange the transfer
  3. Check balances received

First payroll does not mean every balance has arrived.

Start with what you want to improve

Compare written fees, employee support, administration and the work involved. The right result may be a provider move, changes to the existing arrangement or keeping what works.

Changing advisors may also be possible without moving providers. Confirm that the provider accepts the appointment, the paperwork required and the agreed service scope.

What happens during a switch

Use these five stages to agree on the work. Payroll preparation and existing-savings transfers can run alongside each other and finish on different dates.

  1. Understand the current plan

    Record why you are reviewing the plan, its current terms, written fees and unanswered questions.

    Who to involve: Employer and current provider, with RiskX as agreed.

  2. Confirm the new plan arrangement

    Confirm plan terms, services, account setup, employee actions and contribution requirements.

    Who to involve: Employer, incoming provider and payroll.

  3. Prepare new contributions

    Agree on the last and first remittance dates, file requirements, any test process and who checks the amounts credited.

    Who to involve: Payroll and the relevant providers.

  4. Arrange existing savings

    Confirm the transfer method, required authorizations, restrictions, possible investment sales and expected time out of market.

    Who to involve: Both providers, with the employer and members where required.

  5. Confirm what is complete

    Check contributions and transferred balances, assign unresolved differences and tell employees where to find help.

    Who to involve: Employer, payroll and providers within their roles.

Give each track its own dates and checks

New payroll contributions

Confirm which provider receives each pay period's contributions, the remittance deadlines and who checks the first credited amounts. A payslip deduction alone does not confirm that the member's account has been credited.

Assign someone to follow up on rejected files, missing amounts or differences between payroll and member accounts. Agree what employees should be told while a question remains unresolved.

Existing employee savings

Ask both providers how balances will move and which employee authorizations are needed. Confirm possible investment sales, account-access restrictions and expected time out of market. Continuous investment is not guaranteed.

An asset-transfer restriction does not necessarily determine what happens to new contributions. Get instructions for both tracks before communicating dates.

How long should we allow?

About 10–12 weeks

From the decision to the first payroll deduction at the new provider.

This is RiskX's typical planning range, not a guaranteed completion date. Timing depends on payroll integration, data and enrolment; larger plans can take longer.

Existing balances may finish transferring on a different timetable. Confirm dates for account setup, the first accepted contribution file, transferred balances and unresolved differences. Agree who will update you if a date changes.

Confirm the costs before committing

Closing fees, transfer-out charges and reimbursement terms vary. Get written answers for your plan:

  • Which fees apply to the move?
  • Are any fees reimbursed, and under what conditions?
  • Who pays initially, and when would reimbursement happen?
  • What do the written terms cover or exclude?

Your team also puts time into the transition, and money may be out of the market while cash moves. Ask about other charges and who pays them.

Compare one-time transition costs separately from ongoing fees, using the same fee components, assets, period and services. Identify member-paid charges separately from employer costs and contributions. A lower headline fee alone does not establish better value.

If a transfer offer includes a bonus

Ask for the written terms before letting the offer influence your decision:

  • Who qualifies, and who receives the payment?
  • What rate has been agreed, and what fees still apply?
  • When is the transfer considered settled, and when is payment due?
  • What happens after a withdrawal, another transfer or retirement? Could any payment be recovered?
  • What tax questions should your accountant check?

Compare ongoing fees and support separately from the one-time offer.

Tell employees what changes for them

Agree who prepares and sends each update, and where employees can get help.

Before the move

Explain why a change is being considered or made, what is confirmed and what remains undecided. Distinguish account enrolment, transfer authorization and contribution elections where they apply.

As the move progresses

Share confirmed dates, access restrictions and help contacts. Update employees when details change. After the first payroll, explain where to check contributions and the separate status of existing savings.

Questions to settle before committing

Does every employee have to authorize a transfer?

Ask both providers which instructions can be given at plan level and which actions or authorizations members must complete. Confirm who collects them and what happens if something is missing. Do not assume the employer's signature covers every step.

Does switching mean changing our match or DPSP terms?

Confirm which terms can carry across before promising they will stay the same. Review matching, eligibility and contribution arrangements with the receiving provider, and address any DPSP terms separately. Explain any chosen design changes to employees.

How will we know the switch is complete?

Check new contributions and existing balances separately. Agree who resolves differences and how employees can get help. The first payroll file alone does not establish that every part of the move is complete.

Prepared by RiskX

Author: Jarod Smith, CEO. Technical review contact: Gordon Smith. RiskX Insurance Brokers Inc.

Published . Updated .

Sources and scope

Switch timeline is RiskX's own first-party experience of moving Canadian group retirement plans and is confirmed in writing for each plan before a sponsor commits. Transfer-fee treatment, reimbursements and member transaction costs depend on written provider terms, not a universal rule. Plan sponsor review expectations: CAPSA Guideline No. 3 for Capital Accumulation Plans (2024), which is guidance rather than legislation. Information here is general and not individualized advice.

A clearer next step starts with the plan you have

A review may point to a move, a smaller change or keeping the current arrangement. Start with the question you want answered.

Meet with RiskX

Family-owned and Canadian. A partner in helping manage the plan, and in employee education.

RiskX Insurance Brokers Inc.

Family-owned since 1994.
Operationally lean.
Transparent. Still deeply human.

RiskX focuses on group retirement plans for Canadian employers.

Contact

Head Office - Calgary
1005, 930 16 Ave SW
Calgary, AB  T2R 1C2
Toronto Office
36 Toronto Street, Suite 850
Toronto, ON  M5C 2C5

Legal

Projections and illustrations shown are illustrative only and depend on the assumptions stated alongside them. Group retirement plans for employers across Canada outside Quebec, through our partnerships with registered investment providers. RiskX Insurance Brokers Inc. is a family-owned Canadian brokerage, not an insurance company, investment manager or plan administrator. The employer retains responsibility for its retirement plan. RiskX coordinates plan design, education and reviews; individual investment advice belongs to the registered investment provider.